You are currently viewing The “Common Law” Trap: Why ™ Isn’t the Same as ®

The “Common Law” Trap: Why ™ Isn’t the Same as ®

In branding and intellectual property, two small symbols carry enormous legal weight: ™ and ®. They may look similar, but legally they represent completely different levels of protection under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

Understanding this difference can determine whether your brand is secure—or vulnerable.

What Does ™ Actually Mean?

The ™ symbol indicates that you are claiming rights over a mark. You do not need approval from the government to use it. Trademark rights under common law arise from actual use of the mark in commerce.

If you are the first to use a brand name, logo, or slogan in connection with specific goods or services in a particular area, you may acquire limited rights.

However, those rights come with serious limitations.

The Limitations of Common Law Rights

1. Geographically Limited

Common law protection extends only to areas where you can prove reputation. If your business operates in Mumbai, your protection may not automatically extend to Delhi or Bengaluru.

2. Difficult to Enforce

Without a registration certificate, you must prove:

  • Date of first use
  • Extent of goodwill
  • Market reputation
  • Consumer confusion

This makes litigation complex and expensive.

3. Limited Scope

Your rights apply only to the goods or services you are actively offering. Someone else could use or even register the same mark in a different class.

4. Risk of Being Overridden

Another party can apply for and obtain registration before you. Once registered, they gain statutory rights—even if you were using the mark locally.

This is the “Common Law Trap.”

What Does ® Mean?

The ® symbol can only be used once your trademark is officially registered with the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trademarks.

Using ® without registration is illegal.

Unlike ™, the ® symbol represents statutory protection granted by law.

Guide on registered trademark symbol ® meaning and legal registration requirements.

The Power of Registration

Completing online trademark registration gives you:

Nationwide Protection

Your registered mark is protected throughout India—even where you have not yet operated.

Legal Presumption of Ownership

Courts presume you are the rightful owner. The burden shifts to the opposing party.

Strong Remedies

You can seek:

  • Injunctions
  • Damages
  • Seizure of counterfeit goods
  • Recovery of legal costs

These remedies are significantly stronger than passing-off claims under common law.

Business Asset Creation

A registered trademark can be:

  • Licensed
  • Assigned
  • Franchised
  • Valued during investment or acquisition

Ten-Year Renewable Protection

Registration lasts 10 years and can be renewed indefinitely.

Real-World Consequences

Imagine building a successful brand for five years using ™.

You invest in:

  • Marketing
  • Packaging
  • Website
  • Customer loyalty

Then you receive a legal notice. A company in another state has secured registration for your brand name and now demands you stop using it.

You face three painful options:

  1. Rebrand completely
  2. Pay licensing fees
  3. Fight expensive litigation

This happens more often than businesses expect.

Cost vs. Risk

Many business owners hesitate due to trademark registration fees.

In India:

  • Government fee: ₹4,500 (MSME/individual) or ₹9,000 (others)
  • Professional fees vary

Compared to:

  • Rebranding costs
  • Loss of goodwill
  • SEO loss
  • Marketing replacement
  • Legal battles

Registration is a small investment.

If you consult an experienced trademark lawyer in India, you also reduce the risk of objections, classification errors, and delays.

Common Misconceptions

An image showing a wooden stamp creating a "TRADEMARK" seal on paper, alongside text debunking four common myths about trademark ownership and registration.

“I’ve used this name for years.”
Use helps, but it does not equal statutory ownership.

“My company name is registered.”
Company registration does not grant trademark rights.

“I’ll register later.”
Someone else may register first.

“™ gives me full protection.”
It does not.

How Can We Safeguard the Brand Identities of a Company Through Trademarks?

Safeguarding a brand requires a structured strategy:

1. Conduct a Comprehensive Search

Check identical, phonetic, and similar marks across relevant classes.

2. Select the Correct Class

India follows 45 trademark classes. Incorrect classification weakens protection.

3. File TM-A Application

Submit trademark registration online with accurate details.

4. Respond to Examination

If objections arise, timely and strategic replies are critical.

5. Monitor Publication & Opposition

Marks are published for opposition before final registration.

6. Enforce & Monitor

Regularly monitor the market and registry to prevent infringement.

Step-by-Step Guide to Trademark Registration Process

  1. Conduct availability search
  2. Identify correct class(es)
  3. File TM-A application
  4. Receive application number
  5. Examination by registry
  6. Reply to examination report (if any)
  7. Show-cause hearing (if required)
  8. Publication in Trademark Journal
  9. Opposition period (4 months)
  10. Registration certificate issuance

You have to follow step by step Trademark Registration Process and professional handling ensures smoother online trademark registration and minimizes procedural setbacks.

The Legal Benefits of Having a Registered Trademark in India

  • Exclusive nationwide rights
  • Legal presumption of ownership
  • Strong enforcement powers
  • Enhanced brand valuation
  • Ability to license and franchise
  • Protection against counterfeiters
  • Basis for international expansion

 

Under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, registration converts your brand into enforceable intellectual property. These all are the legal benefits of having registered Trademark in India.

The International & Digital Advantage

With global e-commerce and social media, your brand is instantly visible across India and beyond. Common law rights struggle in the digital era.

Through the Madrid Protocol, a registered Indian trademark can serve as the base for protection in multiple countries.

Without registration, your expansion plans remain legally fragile.

Conclusion

The difference between ™ and ® is clear:

  • Claim vs. Ownership
  • Limited rights vs. Nationwide exclusivity
  • Vulnerability vs. Legal strength

Common law rights are temporary and limited. Registration provides certainty and enforceability.

Trademark registration is not an expense—it is brand insurance.

Choose protection.
Choose statutory rights.
Choose ®.

If you are serious about safeguarding your brand identity, securing proper registration, and building long-term legal protection, professional guidance makes a significant difference. You may consider taking assistance from an experienced intellectual property firm like Intellect Bastion, which can help you navigate searches, filing, objections, and enforcement with strategic precision.

Because when it comes to trademarks, prevention is always more powerful—and far less expensive—than correction.

We are unable to save you request. Please try again.
We’ve received your request. One of our expert will reach out to you shortly to discuss in detail.

GET FREE CONSULTATION

The WHATSAPP field must contain between 6 and 19 digits and include the country code without using +/0 (e.g. 1xxxxxxxxxx for the United States)
?
0 selected
/

Intellect Bastion LLP

Intellectual Property Rights (Patents, Designs, Trademarks, Copyrights) Company

Leave a Reply